The Future Of Wi-Fi in 2023 looks bright



hello everybody and thanks for joining today my name is perry carrell i'm director of wireless solutions at extreme networks uh part of my responsibility is also interfacing with the wi-fi alliance the ieee and the the wba the wireless broadband alliance and today we're going to talk about the future of wi-fi and it's not just going to me me we're also going to have zeus joining us today so zeus why don't you tell us a little bit about yourself yeah thanks perry i appreciate the introduction i'm cease caraval a principal analyst with zk research i run my own research firm i've been doing that about oh 10 years before that actually i was the chief researcher yankee group and before that perry i uh i don't have a typical analyst background is actually cio and a network engineer so i've been playing with wi-fi technology ever since there was wi-fi and it's been interesting to see uh the evolution of it to get to the point where we are today where it's really mission critical well that's great because actually if you think about the fact that you've had that background you're not just looking at what's happening you also had to live and breathe that stuff back in the day so it's going to actually lend a little bit of of credibility going forward with with the next slide which you know talk a little bit about the digital transformation what's happening out there yeah digital transformation is kind of a funny thing in fact though uh the covet and pandemic you know that that's going on has actually accelerated i've seen companies really move forward with what they're doing digital technologies now when we think of digital transformation we think things like cloud mobility iot things like that and they may seem somewhat unrelated but the one commonality all those things tend to have is they're all network-centric in nature so the more digital companies become the more network-centric they become and wi-fi is a big part of that in fact if you look at some of the data points this chart 80 billion connected device by 2025 certainly iot is on the rise uh you know we have 4k video um 80 percent of interactions uh in contact centers be completed by ai the clouds you know off the charts and so uh it's it's uh it's my thesis that the network particularly the wi-fi network has now become a foundational component of digital transformation in fact i've worked with a lot of companies and by and large when the digital initiatives fail it was because wireless wasn't really ready i've talked to retailers that have tried to put tablet programs and place schools that have tried to go to online learning things like that and in general when the wi-fi is not ready uh or the it staff wasn't really warned in advance and they couldn't do the proper upgrades those those uh initiatives failed so i'm sure you've seen that through a lot of your customers as well i know you and i have talked about this ad nauseum no no absolutely and that's you know one of the things you hit on that i think is really really important and you kind of mentioned you know what's changed recently with the whole covet thing and all that if you look at i hate to put it this way but have actually advanced wi-fi because if you think about it you know three four five months ago depending on what business you are you closed up your laptop in your office on a friday afternoon and monday you open that laptop in your dining room table and we couldn't have done that without wi-fi mind you everybody's wi-fi might be a little bit different whatever but wi-fi is what's enabled you to work from home to distance learning to telemedicine to all that stuff and that's to your point as far as the numbers growth that's only going to explode those numbers going forward one of the other things i see driving this is the fact that you know maybe you don't always see it but wi-fi the chipsets and that stuff is actually getting cheaper and it allows me to put that stuff into your your iot technology put it in pretty much anything it might not be the latest technology but i'm allowing it to do it and that's where we're going to hit these ridiculous numbers of 15 50 whatever billion number you want to put in there and it's what's driving this industry because nobody's connecting it anymore i mean we we've got offices we're building new office spaces now we're not running cat 5 cat 6 cat 7 cable people are building houses now that they're not running even even um the phone lines because they're assuming everything's going to be wireless and so it is driving this yeah actually it's a it's a strange thing too when you buy even a consumer device and there's no wi-fi interface on it right wi-fi chip in it you you almost look at it like it's some archaic technology so you know you think of even at home garage door openers your refrigerator the alexa type devices everything's wi-fi connected today in fact i uh i recently toured one of the newer stadiums and uh you know wi-fi is a big part of fan experience today and so it's uh you know it's it wi-fi we used to think perry when i was an engineer and i know you've been doing this for a long time wi-fi used to be thought as the network's convenience right and then anything important you get over wired but that's gone away today wi-fi is the network of communities and it's the mission critical network and so this delineation we have do it over wired if it's important do it over wireless for mobility goes away the wi-fi is really the primary and first network today no absolutely and i'm glad you mentioned the uh the the nfl type stuff because obviously extreme's been a primary um a proponent of that and actually we're the official wi-fi vendor of the nfl and it's unbelievable that people go to the games to watch you figure they're going to sit there for three hours and watch the game but the amount of data they generate is unbelievable which kind of brings us to you know we're talking about wi-fi and the different technologies that you know where did we get to today and it's kind of fun to take a look back at the wi-fi evolution and one of the things i always point about the wi-fi evolution is that us as vendors we've caused ourselves enormous amount of problems and reason for that is about every 12 18 24 months we come running out to the customers we come running out to the consultants we come running out to the partners and go have we got a deal for you this brand new technology is going to solve all your problems and give you unlimited performance and quality and we did that for 11 a b g n 150 n 300 ac wave one ac wave two and now we're getting a wi-fi six or eleven ax technology it's important understand the ieee wrote the 11ax standard the wi-fi alliance they certify devices and that's called wi-fi six so that's the confusion between the two but wi-fi six is really really different and people need to understand that and appreciate that do you do you agree i i do it is uh significantly different in fact it's the first wi-fi technology that is that was built with the assumption that we work in an all wireless workplace right so i think all previous versions of wi-fi before six assume that wi-fi augmented what you did with wired i think when they built wi-fi six it's fundamentally different and i've talked to people in the standards body about this it's really um uh built with that the preconceived notion that we that we would be wi-fi first and the other thing you did is across that wired barrier right if you look at some of the speeds uh that you had on the chart before uh perry two mag 11 mag 54 mag 300 mag the wired technology always outpaced wi-fi but today there's been a crossover point right wi-fi is now faster it's past that gig mark we're not running 10 gig wired to the desktop so we actually in theory can get better bandwidth speeds that are wi-fi than we can wired so that's that's a profound change in in the way we think about wi-fi that's pretty interesting you say that because once again i hate to say our ages and stuff but we kind of went we were involved with the evolution of wi-fi and as you said a decade ago was like okay you know i plug in that gives me that performance reliability and stuff and if i need mobility i'll have the wi-fi too now wi-fi is the standard for the applications for reliability for capability for all this stuff and i only deploy wired if i have to and that's important thing to understand going forward because one of the things to understand and appreciate is why we're saying this why wi-fi 6 is different as i said every every iteration us as vendors said this is a great this is the greatest thing that happened but with wi-fi 6 with 11ax we got and i don't want to call it wi-fi switching because your techies freak out about that but now i have the ability to actually talk to more than one user at a time what most people don't realize is that when i've been buying aps for the last 15 years everybody's concerned about associations how many people can i associate this as ap 50 100 200 whatever ridiculous number you want what people don't realize is up until the per 11ax wi-fi six only one device can talk so even though i might have 50 or 200 users associated to that radio i'm only talking one at a time and there's a priority scheme and all that stuff what wi-fi six did and primarily with what's called the ofdma orthogonal frequency division multiple access if you say that you sound very very smart what that allows me to do now is talk to multiple people at one time so it's not just a prioritization scheme thoughts yeah actually i um i think everybody who's probably on this uh watching the session has been this situation where you're in a keynote you're in a lecture hall you're tweeting away you're typing away you're browsing away and all of a sudden everything stops working right and you don't know why that is sometimes you get kicked off sometimes you know but it looks like you're connected looks like you've got signal strength you haven't moved but yet stops not working and that's because that problem you talked about where uh you do it is too congested and it can only talk to one at a time the analogy i've used it's a little bit like if you're in that grocery store line and you're behind that elderly person you know someone that looks like you uh that's right in the check you're counting the change right that that cashier cannot start with your transaction until that person's finished writing that check well what if there was a way while the person is writing the check right that the cashier could start with your order and then pause you and then start with the next order that's what ofdma brings is the ability to almost take all those little gaps in time that you have where the wi-fi is not being used and service the next person so a lot of the things you have on here perry and i know you're very well over this we're taken out of the world the cellular where they had to deal with these problems long ago right so we brought some of those best practices and brought them into wi-fi and so this is why i say it's a fundamentally different type of wi-fi every version of wi-fi up to now has been based on the concept it's just a faster version you know wi-fi it's a faster version of 4x or faster version than three but architecturally it was the same wi-fi six is the first one where we've actually taken a step back and said let's fix all those problems with wi-fi to actually make it as you mentioned uh act a lot more like a wired switch and i know the technical people don't like that but that's that's essentially what it is you know um we didn't script this ahead of time like that but i could actually kind of pay you for what you just said because that's that's the important thing to understand as far is what's changed and how advantage it is and being able to do this that you don't have to prioritize one device well you're still going to have prioritization but to be able to talk to multiple people on time but the other key point and it's very important because a lot of times you know we talk about 11ax we talk about wi-fi six and then you got some customers out there which they're allowed to do that they're going you know i'm not going to be the bleeding edge i'm not going to be the guy who jumps in this technology first and has it fails what's important and what zs just said is none of this is new you look at ofdm you look at longer symbols you look at multi-user mimo you look at twt you look at the obss all these techie terms of what form the components of wi-fi six none of them are new ofdma oh my god it's so new it's so important 2007 wimax that's where it first came and as i said it came out of the cellular side so the a11ax task group what they did is they took workable off the shelf technology yeah they tweaked it and all that stuff but they brought it together to actually advance improve the wi-fi service and it got us to the point now that you know if i have uh voice traffic if i have nurse call systems they don't have to wait anymore because they only need a little bit of bandwidth but it need it consistent so it gives you a much much better so the nice thing about wi-fi six is that it's at the end right that's that's it that's all we're gonna do wi-fi six we're done wi-fi wi-fi yeah yeah that's it uh now there are other things coming out right go ahead yeah yeah i know there are new things coming in fact uh wi-fi seven is already on the horizon wi-fi 6e is coming that's 60 gigahertz version of one in fact uh for people watching this if you want to go into a really nitty gritty depth on how the difference between wi-fi six and six c and i get the sense that a lot of people really don't understand there's difference between six c and six they think it's like wave one wave two with ac but perry and i actually did a q a together it's on network world just if you google my name or perry's name or wi-fi 6e you'll probably find it but uh it does 60 is interesting in that uh it's the first time we're using six euros right for part of wi-fi uh it creates uh some new spectrum for us so we don't get the congestion with all the other older devices that we have uh you know 2.4 goes away so you don't have to worry about those type of devices but it gives us some fresh spectrum to use to actually power a whole new class of devices right so here you and i have talked about so you know what are your thoughts on 6e fresh spectrum that's kind of one way to say it we made you know with 6 gigahertz space they say we double the amount of spectrum i say we quadruple the amount of usable spectrum because in the existing five gigahertz yeah you can have up to 25 available channels but a lot of those you're competing with other technologies and you have to use what's called dfs so you don't interfere especially with doppler radar and stuff with six gigahertz i'm actually getting about four times the amount of usable bandwidth and that's really cool the the analogy i like to use is let's say you're on a freeway around any major city in the united states and it's seven o'clock in the morning and the speed limit sign says 65 and you're doing 16 because there's so much traffic there's so much contention you got a john deere tractor in front of you you had scooters and you look off to your left and there's this brand new highway being built and it's probably 20 lanes wide and the only people allowed on it are formula one race cars because that's the thing about six gigahertz or 6e is that in order to support that it's only going to be wi-fi six or above so you're not as zias just said you're not going to have the older devices competing so everybody's got to be higher performance a lot cleaner spectrum and a lot more spectrum so i don't know what more you can ask about that it's going to give you the best of all worlds uh you know higher level of security lots of channels so vr and ar is actually going to be able to take hold yeah and i've heard people are concerned because a few people have talked about concern about it because it won't support older devices and things we have wi-fi six for that right eventually we get to the point where we do go through device refresh the device manufacturers tend to be fairly aggressive on new radios and stuff they want to have good performance themselves and so i do think that uh you will see device manufacturers tablets laptops things like that pick up 60 in a way to be able to get themselves the best possible experience as well exactly and one final thought you kind of mentioned that 6e the radio itself is not backwards compatible because it only supports six gigahertz but the access points you buy will be they'll support 2.4 and they'll support five gigahertz so that being said we we had a lot of discussion about um wi-fi but do we even need to bother because isn't 5g gonna eliminate the need for any wi-fi and it's all going to go away and those 15 billion devices you're going to have to replace yeah i hear about this a lot from the 5g providers obviously is that get rid of your wi-fi you can go all 5g and i don't i imagine i don't really understand how this would work i don't know too many companies are going to put a sim card in every iot device i don't know how that will work contractually don't get me wrong i think 5g is going to change the world uh but i think it's more of a wan technology and it complements what we're doing with wi-fi very nicely and that i can bring network access now into more places and more time stick with first responder truck i could put a high speed bandwidth and you know with a 5g chip and that but then i could hang a wi-fi access point off it to get wi-fi wireless access to a lot of people right so i i do think 5g is game changing uh by its very nature and that it allows us for as you see here massive iot and enhancement rod banner things but it's a complement to wi-fi not a replacement one of the big things and you and i actually talked about this uh at length that's come up too is the data right if i'm using 5g i'm buying service from service provider they own the data if i want to do my own analytics to understand what's going on you mentioned the nfl i've talked to the nfl about what they want to do with wi-fi they provide us they can understand what social channels people use how they should market uh you know things like that if all of a sudden i'm using 5g for that now i got to go buy my own data back from the 5g provider that's kind of a weird thing so um you know if you if you've watched this and you've read in the public media about how 5g is going to kill wi-fi don't believe it it's a compliment be familiar with how it works and understand where to use it but it doesn't one does not replace the other just like wi-fi six isn't gonna replace uh 5g itself right absolutely that's so important for people to understand that and appreciate that the only people out there that are saying that 5g is going to displace wi-fi in any way shape or form are specific i'm not going to pick on anybody let's just call them carriers in general that it they see that as a you know i don't even want to call it money or whatever but they believe but if you look at things like even the wi-fi alliance they see collaboration between them the wireless broadband alliance collaboration between them everybody's collaborating you know you have these articles where you make it like um like it's an mma competition that 5g versus wi-fi it doesn't exist it's more like the analogy i use is wwe it's like tag team wrestling they're both going to do they both have values and that's the important part going forward and as far as devices as you said but some people right now their phones will support 5g your next phone probably will and definitely you're following after that probably will support some level of 5g even though it's all over the map but how many tablets out there support a 5g interface a cellular interface how many laptops how many wireless printers at home or in your office support a wireless and you know what about your smart tv it's not going to happen you've got approximately 14 billion wi-fi devices out there you're eventually going to have you know about by 2025 you're supposed to have one and a half billion 5g type devices out there it's not going to displace it they're all going to work together 5g wi-fi cbrs uh ultra wide band zigbee z-wave ble they all have special use cases they have areas where they work better than any other technology there's also areas where any one of those technologies can support and then there's there is such a thing as good enough i know people don't want to say that but you know if i deploy 5g anywhere i'm also going to have wi-fi it just you just can't displace it it just can't wait and as a as this was mentioned before right now the biggest thing i'm going to talk about this in a slide or two is everybody's talking about ml ai analytics and stuff and now if i have a femtocell or a microcell in my office or in my house or whenever it's going to be i'm going to connect to that and that's going to forward all my traffic back to the central office i just lost visibility into my analytics as i emphasize that my analytics what's and then obviously there's going to be some type of packages out there to deal with it but i don't know what they're going to be do is yeah no i i brought that up before you you can't be the situation when you're buying your own data back right that's um that's crazy and also that the pricing model doesn't work if you if they really tried to build 5g radios into every tv garage door opener refrigerator how many subscriptions would you need even if they're only charging you a few bucks a month those few bucks a month over i don't know go into your extreme dashboard for the wi-fi at home you probably have 50 60 wi-fi connected devices right so even in a couple of bucks per month for each of those now sudden your bills go way up right so practically speaking unless this unless the the the pricing model and the way the 5g services builder is completely changed just isn't practical no i agree and i think once you get wi-fi at your home i don't care how many devices you hook on it's still free so the next thing is we talked about wi-fi we talked about how exploding what it's going out and managing wi-fi you you have some thoughts about trying to manage wi-fi yeah i did a wi-fi uh troubleshooting survey uh last year and i did this because uh with wi-fi six coming and with digital transformation happening i did say that um wi-fi is a foundational component digital transformation well the way we manage wi-fi must change i think wi-fi troubleshooting is perhaps the most difficult thing there is to do in it partially because somebody you know somebody calls a user i help desk up and says the signal isn't working by the time you even start the troubleshooting process the problem's gone right so uh you can see this data point here just under sixty percent of response to my survey said that they dedicate at least a quarter of their work time uh to troubleshooting wi-fi issues there is not one network engineer that i know that became a network professional so they could troubleshoot wi-fi it's very very difficult to do the other problem is that we don't really have very good tools for this either 59 of the response by survey said they actually they rely heavily on packet capture for wi-fi troubleshooting more than a quarter of the time and if you're using packet capture i don't want to pick a packet capture tools but it is the troubleshooting tool of last resort and and by the time you set it up and you wind up capturing packets the problem could be gone right so i think fundamentally if we're going to make wi-fi the foundation of our digital enterprise we need to change the way we manage and there's so much data being generated today that people cannot correlate the data fast enough we have to rely on artificial intelligence and machine learning and so what i've talked to network engineers about this in the past they look at ai you know they they uh use the technical term they get the heebie jeebies right because it's going to take their job away but make no mistake aim ml is the network engineer's best friend so i know you guys have worked a lot on this what do you see coming here no that's a good point to have because it kind of goes in a couple different ways obviously you mentioned cloud obviously you mentioned the amount of data in this stuff but one of the issues and you already mentioned that with wi-fi wi-fi problems are typically dynamic yeah if the ap fails it's pretty much to figure that out but a lot of times as you said you know i had a problem with my network what had i it was kind of slow i don't know it's kind of working better now but whatever and so what's the first thing that your tech support says to do well can you get me a package capture well if i do it now um everything's working fine it's not going to help me and that's what ai and machine learning and deep uh learning and all this stuff is all about the way i look at it it's all about gathering enormous amounts of data human beings can do this i could hire 50 people to sit there with excel spreadsheets and monitor data all day long but the neat thing about ai the neat thing especially in machine learning is that i can gather enormous amounts of data in our cloud right now we offer the option of unlimited data you don't look back just 30 days or 60 days or 90 days or whatever unlimit as long as you've been on the cloud we'll be able to look back at that data and why that's important is if you have a short-term event and wi-fi a lot of them is you could actually identify that device go back and figure out what happened let me see the hour before the hour after it to 10 minutes before to 10 minutes and tell me what happened at that point and that actually allows me to do some much much better analysis and plus i can i can i can do the mundane stuff i can watch for things that are happening on the network and actually make decisions about that you know we talk a lot about wi-fi because we're kind of brainiacs on there it's like you know dfs is one of the things i was talking about dfs make sure i don't see any um i'm not interfering with doppler radar but you know if i've got an ai system or if i've got a machine learning system that says you know we've been monitoring your network for the last six months we've never seen a uh you know a um doppler radar signature you probably don't have to turn off all those dfs channels you could probably actually use it that's the advantage of ai and machine learning and all that stuff that i can see all this stuff and they make recommendations to you what do you think yeah i actually think it dovetails nicely too in the cloud managed i know extreme and uh companies like you've been working a lot on on shifting a lot of the management of the cloud uh when i think about the compute cycles that are required for ai it's hard to do that on with on-prem systems also the other benefit that you get uh with cloud-based management is you can act i know extremes work on this too is being able to cross-company correlation of data right or just the metadata so you can now make recommendations how to change things and so the the you know what wi-fi what ai does it lets you spot anomalies that are so small that the uh that the human eye can't uh just you can't can't see that and i'll give you a you know a good analogy i was talking to some of the folks at mass general hospital here in the new england area and when they started first started using ai to diagnose mris a lot of the doctors didn't really like it because they thought that's what i'm supposed to be doing but ai can spot like little blame for blame breeds brain bleeds anomalies things like that that you just couldn't spot even with a microscope and so now doctors are spending more time treating patients and less time diagnosing issues same thing with wireless technologies as i mentioned it's one of the hardest things to do as a network engineer i'm sure you'd rather spend more time fixing the problem and redesigning your network and doing the strategic things versus looking through packet capture so if you're tired of looking through reams and reams and reams of data and trying to correlate it manually look to a lot of the artificial intelligence system because to me it's the biggest game changer we've had in networking maybe ever let me give you another example that kind of you know dovetails really really well into what you just said about the mri review imagine i'm managing hundreds thousands tens of thousands of devices ap switches whatever and on this one ap maybe out in the middle of ottumwa iowa or whatever i noticed over the last six months that the internal temperature has incremented up slightly one or two degrees that's got nothing to do with traffic or cpu usage or whatever but i can't detect that as a person there's no way i'm going to do that but if i detect that with machine learning and maybe based on heuristics or based on history i know that that's a signature of maybe a chip going bad or something i can actually resolve that before i have a problem and i can that's the only way you can detect this type stuff and it's very very important understand that and very very important appreciate that so essentially you know what we're talking here is the ability to actually get smarter you know we're talking about you know making your next wi-fi decision and what technology do i want do i do i want to manage via the cloud do i want to leverage ai they all go hand in hand it's tied together and you know appreciate your thoughts to kind of wrap this up for us today zs yeah as i mentioned before i think we're moving into an era that's largely uh digitized right so the wireless network that you have becomes a foundational component in fact if you look at most of the digital technologies out there as i mentioned they're network-centric in nature so you do need a different kind of wi-fi and along with that you do need to think about how to manage your network differently and i think what ai does in the influx of ai and cloud is it takes your your your good engineer it makes them a super engineer right because it gives them insights that they just couldn't have had before and so you know as we the title of this was uh the evolution of wi-fi and why your next upgrade is so important uh it could be one of the most important things uh you know for for your company uh really in the next uh 24-36 months the next wi-fi upgrade is going to be the thing that powers your digital company for the next few years [Music] absolutely and as you said and we said ai is not replacing anything it's another tool it's a very very valuable tool so once again thank you zeus for joining us thank everybody for joining today everybody have a great day

Comments